Delaware Proposes Statutory Framework for Precatory Stockholder Proposals in Response to SEC’s Proposed Rescission of Rule 14a-8

Skadden Publication

Faiz Ahmad Brian V. Breheny Marc S. Gerber Edward B. Micheletti Jeongu Gim Sydney Smith

Executive Summary

  • What’s new: The DSBA Council released a white paper and discussion draft proposing new Section 214 of the DGCL. It would establish a statutory framework governing the submission of precatory stockholder proposals for inclusion in the proxy materials for Delaware corporations.
  • Why it matters: If the SEC rescinds Rule 14a-8, Section 214 would be the exclusive means to present a precatory proposal to stockholders of a Delaware corporation. Proposals would be permitted only at large public corporations with market capitalization of $30 billion or more.
  • What to do next: Companies should consider continuing to monitor the SEC’s final action on rescission of Rule 14a-8 and preparing for these topics to be raised by investors in the course of company-investor engagement.

__________

On November 9, 2026, the Council of the Corporation Law Section (Council) of the Delaware State Bar Association (DSBA) released a white paper and discussion draft proposing new Section 214 of the Delaware General Corporation Law (DGCL) that would establish a statutory framework governing the submission of precatory stockholder proposals for inclusion in the proxy materials for Delaware corporations. The proposed amendments would become effective only if the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) rescinds Rule 14a-8 (and if enacted by the Delaware legislature and signed by the governor).

Below is an overview of the key provisions of the proposed framework.

Background

As discussed in our September 18, 2026, client alert, “SEC Proposes Major Changes to Federal Proxy Rules, Including Rescinding the Shareholder Proposal Rule,” the SEC has proposed rescinding Rule 14a-8 in its entirety, and the SEC indicated its expectation that states would adopt their own standards for inclusion of stockholder proposals in company proxy materials as a matter of state corporate law.

The white paper expresses the view that, if Rule 14a-8 is rescinded, a statutory scheme addressing the inclusion of nonbinding stockholder proposals in company proxy statements is preferable to leaving it to companies and stockholders to develop rules on a company-by-company basis. Neither the DGCL nor Delaware case law directly addresses whether stockholders have a state law right to present precatory proposals, how far a certificate of incorporation or bylaw provision may regulate precatory proposals or whether stockholders may require their inclusion in a company’s proxy materials. The Council has opted for a prescriptive statute that could “immediately replace Rule 14a-8,” rather than leaving companies and stockholders to develop their own alternatives.

Key Provisions of Draft Section 214

Precatory Proposals Permitted Only at Large Public Corporations, With Caps Based on Corporation Size

Draft Section 214 would permit up to three precatory proposals per annual meeting, based on a tiered market capitalization structure:

Tier Market Capitalization Maximum Precatory Proposals per Annual Meeting
Tier 1 $100 billion or more Three
Tier 2 $50 billion to $100 billion Two
Tier 3 $30 billion to $50 billion One
Listed corporations below Tier 3 Less than $30 billion None

When more qualifying proposals are submitted than the maximum permits, the proposals submitted by the three largest stockholder groups based on voting stock ownership would be included in the proxy materials. Later withdrawal or amendment of a selected proposal would not open a slot for another proposal.

 

IPO Grace Period and Opt-Out

  • Five-year grace period. Newly public corporations would have a five-year grace period, measured from initial listing, unless the certificate of incorporation provides for an earlier start.
  • Opt-out. After the five-year period, a corporation could opt out entirely through a certificate of incorporation or bylaw provision adopted at a stockholder meeting (not by written consent) and approved by each class and series of voting capital stock voting separately. An opt-out would eliminate all stockholder-submitted precatory proposals.

Proponent Eligibility

  • Ownership threshold. A proponent must beneficially own either (i) individually, at least $250,000 in market value, or (ii) together with up to nine co-filers, at least $1 million in market value, of voting capital stock. By comparison, Rule 14a-8 currently requires ownership of company stock of $2,000 to $25,000, depending on the holding period.
  • Holding period. Only shares held continuously for at least one year on the 30th day before the submission deadline would count. Market value would be determined, as under Rule 14a-8, using the highest selling price during the 60 days before such measurement date.
  • One proposal per person. Stockholders would be limited to participating as a proponent or co-filer for only one proposal per annual meeting.

Procedural Requirements and Cure Period

The corporation must receive proposals no later than 180 days before the anniversary of the corporation’s prior annual meeting. The proposal and any supporting statement together may not exceed 500 words. Proponents must also deliver proof of ownership and a statement of intent to continue holding the required shares through the annual meeting.

For procedural deficiencies, the corporation must give notice of the deficiency within 14 days of receipt, and the proponent then has 14 days to cure. No other cure opportunity may be provided.

Bases for Exclusion

The white paper lists 12 bases for exclusion. A proposal could be excluded from proxy materials if:

  1. the proponent fails to deliver the required information and documents;
  2. the proposal and supporting statement together exceed 500 words;
  3. the proposal is not timely received;
  4. the ownership requirements are not satisfied;
  5. any part of the proposal or supporting statement expressly questions the character of one or more director nominees;
  6. the proponent submitted a proposal at either of the two preceding annual meetings that received less than 15% of the votes cast;
  7. the proposal primarily seeks to redress a personal claim or grievance;
  8. the proposal seeks a board policy or other arrangement that, if implemented, would provide for precatory proposals in a manner different from, or supplementing, Section 214;
  9. the proponent or a co-filer is a director or officer, is controlled by one, or is acting on behalf of the corporation or a director or officer;
  10. no rational person would determine that the proposal is relevant to the corporation or its business;
  11. the proponent is a proponent or co-filer of another proposal for the same meeting; or
  12. the proponent or any co-filer otherwise fails to satisfy Section 214.

Notably, the draft does not replicate Rule 14a-8’s more subjective bases for exclusion, including the ordinary business exclusion. The white paper notes that one goal of the Council was to develop a framework that was largely objective in order to minimize the risk of litigation between companies and stockholder proponents.

Proxy Placement and Presentation at the Meeting

  • If the corporation solicits proxies, qualifying proposals that are not withdrawn must be included in the proxy statement, with the supporting statement, and on the proxy card.
  • The corporation may include a statement in response or opposition and also explain that the proposal and supporting statement are solely the responsibility of the proponent. 
  • As under Rule 14a-8, no vote would be taken unless the proponent (or its proxy holder) attends the meeting and requests a vote, or the person presiding over the meeting submits the proposal for a vote.

Notice and Dispute Resolution

Within 60 days after the submission deadline, the corporation must notify all proponents of which proposals will be submitted for a stockholder vote. When a corporation excludes a stockholder proposal, the proponent may challenge the corporation’s decision to exclude its precatory proposal by filing suit in the Delaware Court of Chancery within 30 days of the corporation’s determination notice. The corporation bears the burden of establishing that the exclusion was proper.

Exclusivity and Limited Private Ordering

  • Exclusive mechanism. Section 214 would be the exclusive means for stockholders to present a precatory proposal. Proposals beyond the maximum number may not be submitted for a vote even if the proponent were willing to solicit proxies at its own expense, which would effectively foreclose proxy campaigns limited to precatory proposals.
  • No certificate of incorporation or bylaw modification. Certificates of incorporation and bylaws could neither add to nor reduce the statutory requirements; the only private ordering choice would be the binary opt-out described above.
  • Board discretion preserved. The board could still voluntarily submit any precatory proposal to a vote, including a proposal suggested by a stockholder.

Binding Proposals Unaffected

Draft Section 214 would not change Delaware law governing binding stockholder actions, including stockholder proposals relating to the election and removal of directors and the adoption and amendment of bylaws. 

Next Steps

For the 2027 proxy season, expect no changes: Rule 14a-8 would likely remain in effect, although companies would need to navigate exclusion determinations without the SEC staff’s review. In the meantime, companies should consider continuing to monitor the SEC’s final action on rescission of Rule 14a-8 and preparing for these topics to be raised by investors in the course of company-investor engagement into 2027.

The white paper has not yet been approved by the DSBA or the Corporation Law Section, and comments are due by January 8, 2027. Following the comment period, the Council is expected to prepare a revised draft for a vote of the Corporation Law Section and, if approved, the DSBA Executive Committee, before submission to the Delaware General Assembly, which will be in session during the first half of 2027. The Council has emphasized timing: Preparation for the 2028 proxy season will begin shortly after the General Assembly concludes its session in June 2027.

This memorandum is provided by Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP and its affiliates for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended and should not be construed as legal advice. This memorandum is considered advertising under applicable state laws.

BACK TO TOP